The Jerk Toothpaste is a 'harvestable' that was introduced during the Ratboy's Nightmare Update. It is one of the many collectibles that are needed by the players in order to complete the entries of the Itempedia of the Nightmare.
The Jerk Toothpaste can be found in The Supermarket, usually seen on shelves, props, furniture, and objects that can be found throughout the zone. It may also be found in The Back Area, specifically the open rooms bordering next to The Supermarket.
In appearance, the Jerk Toothpaste is a container of toothpaste that may or may not be a safety hazard to their customers. The 'box' container has red, blue, and white streaks seen on the top and sides of the box.
Players may trade in the Jerk Toothpaste to the Gargoyle while making a deal with the NPC, which is collectively known as the Gargoyle's Deals. However, this can only be traded in if and only the deal is available throughout the servers, as one deal can only appear each real-life day.
- The Jerk Toothpaste is not to be confused with the Brain Toothpaste, despite their similar appearances.