The Buttered Greens with Extra Butter is a monster drop that can be found in the Nightmare. It can be found from various sources and locations throughout the Nightmare including but not limited to:
In appearance, the Buttered Greens with Extra Butter is composed of edible greens with a melting stick of butter on top. Players can consume the Buttered Greens with Extra Butter to restore 200 health points and gain a lifetime long +1 HP Regen stat bonus. If the player has no purpose for the Buttered Greens with Extra Butter, it can be sold for 25,000 gold.
- The Buttered Greens with Extra Butter can be seen in several places in the Frontier as a prop before the release of the Ratboy's Nightmare Update.
- The consumable can be seen as a prop displayed in several spots of The Deli's kitchen.
- In-game, its description states that it restores 500 HP, though the item only restores 200 HP.